Biomonitoring of DEET and DCBA in Canadian children following typical protective insect repellent use
- DOI
- Language of the publication
- English
- Date
- 2022-12-09
- Type
- Article
- Author(s)
- Gibson, Jennifer C.
- Marro, Leonora
- Brandow, Danielle
- Remedios, Lauren
- Fisher, Mandy
- Borghese, Michael M.
- Kieliszkiewicz, Katarzyna
- Lukina, Anna O.
- Irwin, Kim
- Publisher
- ScienceDirect
Abstract
N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide (DEET) is an ingredient found in many consumer insect repellents and its use is recommended to Canadians by government agencies, including Health Canada, for protection against insect bites including mosquitos and ticks. The majority of research on DEET exposure and toxicokinetics in humans has focused on adult populations with little information from vulnerable populations, including children. We aimed to fill this knowledge gap by examining real-world exposure data for DEET and its metabolite 3-diethylcarbamoyl benzoic acid (DCBA) in a sample population of Canadian children. We conducted a 24-h observational exposure human biomonitoring study at three overnight summer camps in Ontario, Canada through July and August 2019. Participating children aged 7–13 years provided multiple spot urine samples over a 24-h period and completed a journal to document insect repellent use and factors that could influence absorption of DEET. Children were instructed to use insect repellent as they usually would while attending a summer camp. Exposure was quantified using the information from the participant's journal and the change in the mass of their insect repellent containers over the course of the study. A total of 389 urine samples were collected from 124 children. Among participants using insect repellent, urinary levels of DEET were elevated between 2 and 8 h post-application and decreased thereafter but remained qualitatively higher than concentrations in participants who did not use insect repellent on the study day, even at 18–22 h post-application. DCBA was the predominant metabolite of DEET exposure in urine. DCBA was elevated between 8 and 14 h post-application, and declined thereafter, but not to the level observed among those who did not use insect repellent on the study day. Children who used more insect repellent, or used higher concentration insect repellent (10%–30% DEET) excreted higher levels of DEET and DCBA. Excreted DEET and DCBA accounted for 0.001% (median) and 1.3% (median) of the estimated applied DEET, respectively. Children did not reach an undetectable level of DEET or DCBA in urine, even among those not using insect repellent during the study day, indicating a potentially complex multi-route exposure to insect repellents in a real world scenario. This work provides targeted biomonitoring data for children intentionally using DEET-based insect repellents for normal protective use, and will support the risk re-evaluation of DEET by Health Canada.
Plain language summary
Health Canada helps to protect the health of Canadians by assessing and managing the health risks associated with exposure to environmental contaminants. This research addresses a knowledge gap in the literature regarding the exposure of Canadian children to DEET-based bug sprays when they are using them as they would normally to protect against bug bites. Personal insect repellents, commonly referred to as bug sprays, are important to help protect against biting insects like mosquitoes and ticks. The most common and one of the most effective ingredients in bug sprays is DEET. DEET is the common name for N,N-diethyl-meta-toluamide. This study compared the reported behaviour of bug spray use and daily camp activities of 124 Canadian children with DEET and DEET metabolite 3-diethylcarbamoyl benzoic acid (commonly called DCBA) measured in collected urine samples over the course of a 24 hour period. Researchers used time difference models to align urine samples with bug spray application times, to take into account absorption, distribution, and excretion of DEET and metabolites. The time differences examined were 0, 2, and 4 hours between the relevant bug spray application and urine sampling times. DCBA was the main compound measured in the urine samples. Children who used more bug spray, or higher DEET percentage bug spray, excreted more DEET and DCBA. However, the amount of DEET and DCBA excreted by the children was very low compared to what it is thought they applied to their skin. We estimate that only 0.001% of what they applied was excreted as DEET, and 1.3% of what they applied was excreted as DCBA. It also seems that the 2 hour time difference model explains the results best. This study demonstrates that a real world exposure scenario can produce viable and informative human biomonitoring data, to help reduce the uncertainties associated with the risk assessment of children's exposure to environmental chemicals. This study was conducted to provide modern, relevant exposure data to support the legislated re-evaluation of DEET.
Subject
- Health,
- Health and safety